Is a $135,000 fine appropriate for a bakery that refused to bake a wedding cake for a lesbian couple?

Vanessa Bowman
fashion designer | Germantown
"No. That seems excessive. A fine like that doesn’t fix the problem. It just creates more separation and division. The ignorant just get angry and lash out. So you’re not accomplishing anything with such a fine. I’d rather see some type of mediation."


Naimah Cann
patient-services representative | Overbrook
"Yes. The bakery had no right to pass judgment on the couple. They should be focused on customer service and the quality of their product — things like whether their cake has the right frosting or enough buttermilk. They shouldn’t be judging the lifestyle of their customers. Don’t have a public business if you’re going to be so close-minded."


Jeffrey Dentz
baker | West Philadelphia
No. I sympathize with the lesbian couple. They shouldn’t have been turned away but, in this situation, putting a price tag on the wrongdoing seems a bit absurd. The bakers should change their behavior — not because of a fine, but because they changed their minds."


Michaela Mink
student | Society Hill
"No. I could see a $50,000 fine but a $135,000 fine seems over the top. I fully support the government for fining the bakery, but do it in a way that’s reasonable to most people. If the fine is too high, it makes pro-LGBT people look heavy-handed."


Newsletter Sign-up