Why I'm voting for Babette Josephs
by Chris Pinto
Apr 19, 2012 | 2718 views | 8 8 comments | 16 16 recommendations | email to a friend | print
The Babette Josephs/Brian Sims matchup has garnered a lot of heated discussion in our community and rightfully so. Incumbent Babette Josephs has spoken on our behalf for decades. She has singlehandedly prevented bills from moving to the House floor that were outright discriminatory to the LGBT community. And now, we are in a position where an openly gay male is mounting a well-funded campaign against her.

Babette Josephs is the senior-most female legislator in the Pennsylvania House of Representatives. She, for over 27 years, has tirelessly worked on behalf of women’s wellness, and her record is second to none. She was the lone advocate for gay rights when no one dared to even utter the word “gay” in the state legislature. She took on the powerful gun lobby to reduce the amount of illegal guns and assault weapons on the streets. Every single time in the past 27 years, when legislators decided to legislate on their own personal morals, Babette has been in their face, with her signature backpack, to stop them dead in their tracks. Transit funding, school advocate, rights and protections for seniors — the list goes on. And she’s done this with no state car (she uses public transportation) and a lean staff (efficient and effective). And there’s never a time where Babette won’t spend time with the people in her district.

Brian Sims is not a native to the district and, in fact, he’s not native to Philadelphia. His work experience is anemic when compared to the comprehensive list of national publicity that he’s garnished as the “out” football player at Bloomsburg University. From his website, he’s actively practiced law for approximately one year, on his own. I’m not sure how any of this equates to being qualified or capable of representing or even understanding the issues and the people of the 182nd District, when, for the majority of his personal and professional life, he’s lived outside of the very district he’s running to lead.

There’s absolutely nothing that Brian has said in this campaign that differs from what Babette has said, and has delivered on, for years. So, if there’s no difference in policy, why would anyone actively mount a campaign against a person that he worked for just 24 months prior?

Brian had the opportunity to run in his former district for Kenyatta Johnson’s seat and he declined. He decided to move to the 182nd District and challenge our staunchest ally in the state House. Anyone running for this level of state office has to plan a run like this years in advance. If you look at the dates of his campaign announcement, his contributors and his actions in those 12 months after his work with his opponent, this wasn’t a move driven by personal reasons. I am insulted that people would even believe this is a matter of “coincidence.”

Mr. Sims worked for his challenger just 24 months ago, as treasurer for her campaign. After having access to all of her campaign information, and her successful reelection, his camp claims that by a series of “coincidences,” he would move for personal reasons, and then decide to challenge the one person that we’ve supported as a community for decades (almost immediately after the conclusion of her campaign).

This is not a “coincidence.” This is a calculated betrayal of someone who has selflessly spoken up for us when no one else dared to.

I am offended and outraged at Mr. Sims’ actions. I am disgusted that many people in this community have been blinded by the singular notion that being gay trumps experience and steadfast support for three decades.

We can say that we want an out candidate, but what are we willing to sacrifice for it? Are we that fickle of a community that we embrace someone who has betrayed our staunchest statewide ally and, by his own campaign literature, is clearly unaware of the needs of his constituents? Are we willing to sacrifice a ranking ally in the House for a freshman whose ethics are compromised before he even walks in the door?

Thanks to the many pioneers who have gone before us, we will win a seat not simply because we are gay. We will win a seat because we are qualified to do the job, and do it because we understand the people who we are representing.

We as a community cannot and should not turn our backs on someone who has an exemplary record of protecting us. We have fought discrimination all of our lives and have no right to discriminate against someone because of their gender or sexual orientation. Babette has done and continues to do the job exceptionally well. To vote any other way would reverse years of fighting for gender and racial equality, and will do us all more harm than good.

I have faith that the residents of the 182nd District will vote for Babette. And I hope that after the election, Sims will reevaluate his short-lived, self-proclaimed contributions to our community. Because true LGBT advocates work selflessly toward the cause, above and beyond their own personal aspirations, for the good of the community.

Chris Pinto is a marketing and communications executive and resident of the 182nd District since 2002.

Comments
(8)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
itsbd
|
April 21, 2012
Just a quick layer of perspective to add to this.

We wouldn't just be electing an openly gay leader, we'd unseating the highest seniority and staunchest advocate for LGBT rights in the state legislature and installing a freshman.

"Ideas" can come from anywhere (isn't that part of the reason PGN exists, to leverage an under-heard voice into the conversation?). What you can't replace is the procedural power that comes from having someone on your side who has survived enough battles to gain an important committee chair. In a state like PA that seems to tread water a few lengths behind the arc of history in terms of LGBT civil rights, Mr. Pinto is correct that having a committee chair in place who can put some weight down on destructive and unjust bills is invaluable.

Symbolic victories feel good, but they don't do much good.
182nd Voter
|
April 23, 2012
That's just the issue. Babette doesn't have anymore weight. Her colleagues on BOTH sides of the allies simply don't work with her. For Republicans, she's burned every bridge, and for Democrats, her signature on a bill or as a co-sponsor scares away other votes. She's on the right side of the debate, but she is no longer part of the conversation.

VOTE BRIAN SIMS TOMORROW #111!
CharlieFer
|
April 25, 2012
Guess it sucks to be on your side today, huh?
Viewing_Afar
|
April 19, 2012
27 years is a long time for anyone to be in office. Many of us realize that Babette has always supported the LGBTI community but the time has come for new ideas and approaches to government. We can't expect things to change if we keep doing the same thing and electing the same people.
Out_with_Babette
|
April 19, 2012
Once again a Babette support has nothing positive to say about her but simply blast Brian Sims with falsehoods. Shame on Chris Pinto!
Gayborhood Gal
|
April 19, 2012
This piece is vile! The title says "Why I'm Voting for Babette" then goes off on a tirade of made-up facts, lies, and bitter innuendo. Why ARE you voting for Babette, Chris?

Brian Sims has made a career out of helping LGBT youth both in and out of the sports community. He has made a career of bringing people together to create progressive change. Babette simply spouts off progressive points, BUT NEVER ACTUALLY DOES ANYTHING ABOUT IT! She hasn't passed a bill since 1996!!

In 27 years, this article can't seem to mention any concrete accomplishments of Babette's? Maybe it's because they are few and far between.
FutureSeeker
|
April 19, 2012
Was this a Pro-Babette piece or an anti-Sims piece? It's interesting that the Pro-Sims piece was actually about him and his qualifications and this, well this is kinda of strange, bitter rhetoric.

The best case you can make for a 30-year incumbent is that she's not the guy you seem to bitterly hate?

Also, it may help your argument more if you got any, or even some, of the facts about this guy right. Maybe a google search? That doesn't seem to be a concern of yours but you lost me as soon as you started making facts up.

There are lots of reasons to support Babette, you named none of them. Sims has lots of qualifications himself, you dismiss all of them.

Admit it, this guy turned you down on Craigslist and you've never gotten over it?

Oh, and bitterness, cattiness, and in-fighting are why we've never elected an openly gay leader before.
ReaphWhatYouSow
|
April 26, 2012
Mr. Pinto, has the Sims campaign called to thank you yet?

It looks like this was a very close margin of victory and I think everyone would agree that your vitriolic, hate-filled, DISHONEST, rants about Mr. Sims drove everyone I know away from Rep. Josephs and to Sims.

They owe you some champagne, sir. You taught a bunch of people why change was necessary.