Pride dilemmas and position
Dec 09, 2010 | 2994 views | 12 12 comments | 13 13 recommendations | email to a friend | print
Open letter to the LGBT community from Philly Pride Presents:

There will be two large gay events on Sunday, May 1, 2011. So as not to cause any additional confusion, we, the coordinators, the Pride committee and the staff of the Philadelphia Gay Pride organization, decided to inform our LGBT community of the dilemma we were facing and the decision we were compelled to make.

For years, we have coordinated the two largest gay events in the City: the June Gay Pride Parade and Festival as well as OutFest in October. In the early 1990s, another group, originally called “PrideFest,” organized a weeklong series of events in May. We tried very hard, both privately and publicly, to have “PrideFest” move to June and culminate with our parade and festival. We believed, and still believe, that it would be a spectacular series of events for our community and really put Philadelphia on the gay map. Indeed, in 1994, we moved our pride parade and festival to May to demonstrate how it could be done. That same year, we also created “OutFest,” the National Coming Out Day Block Party, and it was the largest attended community event ever organized in Philly. The following year we decided to return to June (Gay Pride Month), and “PrideFest” advertised a new event — Sunday Out — “because there would be no Gay Pride Parade and Festival.” Of course, that was a slight prevarication as there indeed was a parade and festival, albeit not in May. And, although we were promised that Sunday Out would only be a craft fair, it quickly became a copy of OutFest, and in the very same location as OutFest.

It has long been a bone of contention between our two organizations that one month prior to our festival there is another festival with most of the same vendors and community groups. Philly Gay Pride had to contend itself with doing the two best events we could as we could not convince “PrideFest,” now “Equality Forum,” that this was confusing to the LGBT community and vendors alike. We frequently had many ask, “Didn’t you already have your pride event in May?” when we sought their applications. This year, however, Equality Forum has outdone itself because, after our 20-plus years in making the Great Plaza at Penn’s Landing the best Gay Pride Festival location in the United States, Equality Forum has decided to move Sunday Out to Penn’s Landing!

We are now faced with an event that mimics our Gay Pride Festival — entertainment, community groups, vendors — in our long-established location ... and one month earlier. This could not be more catastrophic to Philly Gay Pride, as the festival is the event that pays for itself as well as the parade and, if any funds are left over, provides seed money for OutFest.

June is officially National Gay Pride Month and we are not the only LGBT Pride event in the greater Philadelphia and tri-state area. People will want to go to D.C., Baltimore or Pittsburgh for their pride events on our date because they already “did” Philly’s pride festival at Penn’s Landing in May. The only way to have our traditional attendees, volunteers and vendors at our event in June is to make sure they are not participating at the same type of event and location (Penn’s Landing) in May. Therefore, on Sunday, May 1, we will be having a May Gay Day block party in the Gayborhood. Our event will be free to participants (as is OutFest); however, it will also be free to community groups and vendors if they have applied for the Gay Pride Festival in June. It should be spectacularly successful, as OutFest 2010 drew approximately 40,000. Vendors are getting two events for the price of one, so they will certainly be present. The bars and various Gayborhood businesses will participate and will offer special events. We will have entertainment, a dance area, food, spirits, a pet zone, a family area and at least 20,000 celebrating Gay May Day in the Gayborhood.

Imitation might be the sincerest form of flattery, but we can ill afford to be flattered into nonexistence. Our choice is either to have Gay May Day or be financially compromised, and we have all worked too hard for too long to not fight back.

We look forward to our 80-plus community organizations and 50-plus vendors joining with us on Gay May Day because we are an umbrella organization that depends on the full support of our community for the success of our events. We apologize for any confusion, but it was not a confusion of our making. For more details or an application, feel free to check our website, www.phillypride.org.

Philly Pride Presents Inc.

Comments
(12)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
phillyccgwm
|
December 23, 2010
Wise move Frannie. Equality Forum (aka Malcom-fest) because of their horrendous choice of location last year - Piazza in Northern Liberties. Pride already agreed once to move their parade and festival to be the Sunday of the week of Equality Forum, I have seen no similar flexibility on Equality Forum's part to try and compromise. Plus Frannie making this move brings an event back to the Gayborhood, where we can support local neighborhood merchants, rather than nameless concessionaries at Penn's Landing.
G.Campbell
|
December 19, 2010
I would think that multiple events spread across multiple consecutive months would be a very good thing for the LGBT community. It serves to keep our messages out in the public eye, with frequency instead of sheer one time volume impact. Anyone in advertising will tell you that multiple smaller ads over extended periods of time with planned frequency will have a far greater impact than one big one. Get over the pride of ownership and ego crap and get back to the welfare of the community, where your non-profit belongs.
The Banker
|
December 17, 2010
Isn't EF on the verge of bankruptcy? Just throw in the towel already!
FormerlyPhilly
|
December 17, 2010
Glad I left this city. Back stabbing, lies, and all the crap makes you wonder - are they for the community or just themselves?

We all know that answer.
anonymous
|
December 16, 2010
I refuse to go the Gay May Day and will call for a boycott of such an event. Both events should be able to exist. Chuck Volts and Fran Price should be ashamed of themselves for splitting the gay community like this. Philly Pride needs to step aside and let the EF event take place as is. Protestations should be send to Fran Price at phillygaypride@aol.com
Concerned Queer
|
December 16, 2010
I refuse to go the Gay May Day and will call for a boycott of such an event. Both events should be able to exist. Chuck Volts and Fran Price should be ashamed of themselves for splitting the gay community like this. Philly Pride needs to step aside and let the EF event take place as is. Protestations should be send to Fran Price at phillygaypride@aol.com
Concerned Queer
|
December 16, 2010
I refuse to go the Gay May Day and will call for a boycott of such an event. Both events should be able to exist. Chuck Volts and Fran Price should be ashamed of themselves for splitting the gay community like this. Philly Pride needs to step aside and let the EF event take place as is. Protestations should be send to Fran Price at phillygaypride@aol.com
Chuck Volz
|
December 12, 2010
I have been a pride coordinator since 1994. From the very begininings of Equality Forum as Prifefest, Philly Gay Pride has attempted time and time again to coordinate our two events, without success. We have now been forced to fight for our very existence by this questionable move to Penn's Landing. Protestations should be addressed to Equality Forum at mlazin@equalityforum.com. Tell Malcolm Lazin its time to start thinking about Philadelphia's LGBT community as a whole.
grandpajojo
|
December 10, 2010
Equality Forum promotes itself as the best-attended, annual 'international' LGBT event, an unsubstantiated assertion as far as I can tell (two or three gay Russians does not an international conference make), but probably a useful one to understand this situation. As a 'premier,' 'global' player, it's beneath Equality Forum to share credit with a local organization. Rather, everyone should be grateful to follow in its wake. The truth is that these organizations, both of which rely on regional funders to survive, offer our community almost identical events. A practical solution for the current situation might be for the donors who support both organizations to withhold contributions until they agree to work together.
philly pride
|
December 10, 2010
there will be "prideday" LGBT Pride Parade and Festival in 2011 sunday june 12
Anonny too
|
December 10, 2010
Amen and amen. And I'm not a prayin man.

I agree 95% with Anondeplume (EF is more a week-long series of parties with a smattering of educational workshops and discussions. In fact, when it was in the dead of winter years back it WAS about education) but still, there is so much more that this community deserves and wants than this BS.

I'll even go this far: If the embittered parties were to have an open-house forum where the community was invited to PARTICIPATE in the process, you'd have to have it over a three-day weekend at the Gershman to accommodate everyone, their ideas and the volunteer lists would be full.

Then the Philadelphia area would eagerly anticipate Pride as a community event for a week. Maybe Latino Pride and Black Pride and the Dyke March could all be encompassed so that we are not continuing to further segregate ourselves.

Please, you people are really driving us apart.

And away.
Anonynomdeplume
|
December 10, 2010
This is a sad day for Philly. No Gay Pride event in 2011. And why? Because Philly Pride Presents and Equality Forum organizers will not work together. This is a shame. And shameful. Big egos are preventing constructive dialog. Rarely, if ever, is this kind of situation one-sided. I would like to propose that both Malcom Lazin and Franny Price/Mark Segal agree to enter into mediation with each other. Have them set their egos aside and work it out. Once that is done, maybe Philly can have BOTH a week-long series of educational workshops AND a gay pride event. Gee, what a novel friggin idea!

Mark my words: ALL of the gay community is tired of these politics, egos and posturing. We are all "putting up with it". It's a real drag. And frankly, those in charge of these events should start working together or we will all continue to wait for the leaders of these groups to grow old, move away or die. Seriously. The bitterness these ego battles has engendered in the community contributes to ill feeling amongst the vast majority of gay Philadelphia. In other words, we're sick of it. Really really really sick of it. And BOTH are to blame. Period.